
Title: Grace
Author: A.M. Shine
Release date: February 12th, 2026
Huge thanks to the author, Netgalley and the publisher for a digital ARC of this one!
Back in the Halcyon days of Kendall Reviews, Gavin DM’d me to ask if I’d like to check out the debut novel of a new Irish horror novel. It was titled ‘The Watchers’ and the synopsis had me very intrigued. I read it, loved it, raved about it, and subsequently have enjoyed another two novels from one A.M. Shine. Shine, on his end, has hit homerun after homerun with his debut, the sequel (‘Stay in the Light’) and the horrifying ‘The Creeper,’ and ‘The Watchers’ was adapted into film and became a smash hit for Netflix.
All of that is to say, that I was beyond surprised when Shine DM’d me recently to ask if I’d be keen on reviewing his next novel. Truth was, after seeing it announced, I’d already preordered the Kindle edition, as I was certain a novel of this magnitude wouldn’t be available to request on Netgalley when it went live.
As with each of Shine’s books, there are three things you can expect. The first is remote location. The second is quality, well-fleshed characters. And the third is an absolutely creepy-as-all-hell atmosphere that seemed to blanket my Kindle with the same fog that appeared within this one.
I dove in, excited to learn what terror Shine was delivering this time, knowing full well that I’d be wishing I was sleeping with a light on.
What I liked: What happens when you take ‘The Reddening’ by Adam Nevill, ‘Eynhallow’ by Tim McGregor and ‘Behemoth’ from H.P. Newquist and mix them all in a blender? You get ‘Grace’ from A.M. Shine.
The novel follows a young woman, Grace, who discovers that she was adopted as a child. Her mother has passed away and has left her house to her. The only problem is that the house is on Croaghnakeela Island, some hundreds of kilometers away. Grace isn’t even familiar with the island and discovers she needs to take a boat – which even then is a challenge to arrange – to get to the island. The boat operator won’t step foot on the island, believes it to be cursed, but Grace doesn’t believe in such things.
Croaghnakeela Island is real – I Google mapped it, lol, but it’s safe to say Shine has taken significant liberties with the place, judging by what Google Maps shows. Saying that, the island does have Tobar Cáillín Holy Well, a religious relic, which seems to have inspired one aspect of the story. You see, the residents there toss coins into this ‘well,’ wanting to appease a benevolent creature that seems to be the root of this curse. And while I won’t spoil what this creature is, I will say that I have a short story inspired by the folklore behind it and have always found it fascinating, so when it popped up here, I was elated.
Shine sets things up nicely. We see the rise and fall of the island’s inhabitants. We are shown what might be the opening that allowed such a thing to arrive on the islands shorefront to begin with, and we see the cracks form between friends and ultimately the trust fail as they come to grips with what must be done to rid themselves of the islands infection.
I loved the characters Shine introduces, each one a crusty, weathered individual who you instantly like and dislike in equal measure. We learn of previous attempts to leave the island and we get the shit scared out of us time and time again.
The final quarter is revelatory. We learn secrets, we see some folks step up and do what needs to be done while others cower and show who they really are. And all the while Shine layers this last section with more fog and more insanity. It created a reading experience that was claustrophobic, visceral and had my heart jackhammering in my chest. Which led to an ending – and epilogue – that delivered exactly what I hoped for.
What I didn’t like: Funny story on this part. When Shine messaged me he even mentioned how he knew I don’t often mesh well with books with POV changes from chapter to chapter – which is what this book does. Hilariously (take that Shine!) that aspect worked phenomenally for me.
Instead, the one aspect that I wasn’t totally sold on for a bit was the dampening of Grace’s storyline (though it was necessary) and the switch to the Reverend. At least, I think he was a Reverend? I’m totally drawing a blank right now. I loved his character, but for me, Grace’s story drew me in far more than his, though his was paramount to what happens and how we get to the ending.
Why you should buy this: Over the last few years, A.M. Shine has cemented himself as a both a ‘must-read’ author for me but also one of a handful of authors who can easily scare the pants off me. His ability to create scenes and a tangible atmosphere in his books is world class and ‘Grace’ easily slots itself into the category of ‘Best Folklore Horror Novels of the Last 10 Years.’ Taking cues from ‘Starve Acre’ and ‘Cunning Folk,’ Shine wastes no time delivering creeps.
If you’ve not yet read any of A.M.’s work, this is a fantastic leaping in point. If you’re a dedicated Shine fan already, then you’ll be chomping at the bit to see release day arrive.
This novel turns the shadows in the corner darker, the blackness of the night blacker and the fog in the air thicker. And I can’t thank Shine enough for reminding me that sometimes the scariest things in lonely places are the ‘things’ that go bump in the night.
Fantastic.









